I checked that mouth on him
Fucking checked that gas on him.
I had him, cornered him
Fucking shut that gate on him
Why would you listen to him?
He had his way, I’m bored of him.
I’m tired of him
I don’t wanna be as bad as him
-M.I.A.
You left g r e a t
b i g g a p s
That I just can’t seem to fill.
—
It’s a prematurely warm night in early May, and we’re on our weekly phone call. We have a routine now. A few teasing texts back-and-forth on Fridays as I finish up my classes for the week and head off to meet Jayne for lunch at the SUB. And each Wednesday night you call me after your film class. Usually you catch me on my way to the Rec Center and we talk for a few minutes before I promise to call back later, or sometimes I slip into the locker room after a run, drenched in sweat and breathless, Muse or Modest Mouse blasting in my ears, to find a voicemail from you. I go home and make macaroni and cheese with Nikki, then call you back as I devour all the calories I just ran off, plus a glass of grape juice.
It started while it was cold out, but now the snow has melted for good and I’ve returned to riding my bike to campus at night. I love standing on the pedals and zipping down hills at break-neck speeds, hair whipping behind me like a small child. These solo rides are the first real tastes of happiness I’ve had in years.
Tonight I pedal slowly, weaving in the near-darkness as I steer one-handed. The other hand clasps my pink phone to my face, which is flushed as we talk. You’re saying you might stay up north this summer. I pause, then say, all in one breath, ‘I hope you make whatever choice is best for you, but I just want you to know, if you stay there, there is going to be a girl in Kansas City who will really miss you.’ Woosh.
That put it on the line – the one we’ve been toeing for weeks now, since I sent you a text that threw everything in the air with so few words: I still like you. I’m sorry for saying this while you had a girlfriend, but I was sitting in a basement with two old friends, drinking coffee and listening to Bob Dylan on vinyl. Sometimes the moment is right, never mind other attachments and all the details like how we spend three-fourths of the year nearly eight hours apart. I was so sure of it. And you put your arm around me in the hotel lobby when I took a school trip to Minneapolis, and you didn’t take it away when the joking moment was gone. You left it for awhile (she was your girlfriend then, too). And it felt so comfortable. You’ve always felt so comfortable. From flirting on the school bus to falling asleep together in your basement watching movies after football games, it’s been right, plain and simple.
You don’t miss a beat. ‘Aww,’ you say, and I can hear the smile in your voice. It’s the same smile that will mark my life change five months from now when I sit in your lap and tell you I love you for the first time.
These moments, they never go away. They are always perfect. They are always the safety of twilight, wrapped up in your devil-may-care grin and knowing that for a second, someone else in this world breathed in exact synchronization with me. They are warm, permanent, secure and at times, the only thing I believe in much anymore.
Why you? Why can’t I take it back?
Those moments changed everything, and somehow, I don’t think any of it is done quite yet. I still can’t talk about it, write about it, even think about it much. You are still this giant empty hole that I can’t approach enough to start patching.
I see now that I was looking for you in him. He will never be honest or serious with me though, will never be content to sit in a parking lot at midnight talking about religion and video games and all those little in-betweens. There is no substance. Traces are the same, but the parts of you that meant the most will never be part of him. That’s exactly why I wanted him so badly.
S. last week said I’m the one he wishes he could have a second chance with, a do-over. I couldn’t say anything. Once, so recently, I wanted the same with him. That was before you. After you, how could anyone else compare?
I’m still tired, so tired like I told you I was in March. Too tired to chase after you or anyone else. Too tired for playing. Too bored and stagnant to do anything but walk away from this. Somehow I am still worn and broken. When he called the other night after six months of silence, it was you on the other end of the phone. It was your voice that made my knees give out, leaving me to sink onto the edge of my bed. His words were kind, surprisingly apologetic, whereas the last memories I have of you hurt. I could hear the alcohol in your voice, and the disdain you use for things you’ve logically convinced yourself you don’t need.
I know just where it began. Where does it end?